Reading by Series vs Trope

This is a problem that I think is largely unique to romance, but do you tend to read more in order of a series, or skip around based on the trope you like? Growing up I had favorite authors from whom I’d read anything, but when looking into new books, I didn’t worry at all about the book being part of a series, and instead read whichever one sounded most interesting to me.

I’m not sure when that changed, but it really became apparent when I was talking to a friend the other day who reads by trope. She was giving me all kinds of recommendations, and when I mentioned that I didn’t care for the first book in a few of the series she was talking about, she realized that she’d never actually read the first book! And she didn’t really want to. She was happy with the later books she’d read and loved, and reading them out of order didn’t make much of a difference to her ability to understand and enjoy them.

I’m not sure when I started insisting on reading in series order, because most romances are written so that it doesn’t matter (Psy/Changeling is an example of an exception — read that series in order!). I think there’s some value to reading them in order because you can enjoy the sequel bait and anticipate new books in the series, and it’s fun to see old favorite characters pass through the pages of a book. But clearly it’s not always the best way to read, as sometimes an earlier book isn’t necessarily the one that’s going to grab you the most.

I think part of why I started reading more in series order than I did when I was younger is because I now have more established favorite authors whose books I read as they’re published, which means I’m reading them in order without meaning to. And I think that’s trained me to read in order when looking for new authors to try.

I want to try breaking that habit a little bit, though, and go back to reading more books solely based on description and tropes. Especially as I dive further into historical romance and give new authors a try, I don’t want to worry so much about reading the first book in a series, but more on which one I think I’m most likely to enjoy.

I was thinking of maybe doing this for some of the Avon authors I’d like to check out for KissCon but wasn’t familiar with, as well as a bunch of my friend’s recommendations. It’s actually a bit scary now that I’m faced with actually reading books out of order, just because I’ve become so used to doing it that way. But it should be fun! My favorite authors don’t always write my favorite tropes, so this allows me to really revel in the tropiness (enemies to lovers! just one bed! forced proximity! marriage of convenience! sunshine and grump!). We’ll see how it goes!

Do you read more by series order or trope? Let me know in the comments!

6 thoughts on “Reading by Series vs Trope

    • Yeah, I think preferring to read books in order is a pretty popular way to do it! I definitely feel my skin crawl a little at the idea of not reading a series in order

      Liked by 1 person

  1. First and foremost, yay Kisscon! I am nervous if it’ll happen this year though.

    I tend to read series which is also why I tend to avoid series. People will gush about their favorite book in a series, and while I’d like to experience their favorite book, I don’t have the energy to read X amount of books to get to their fave.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Fingers crossed for KissCon! If nothing else, it’s something to look forward to at the end of all of this.

      That’s so interesting that you avoid series! That’s actually kind of impressive, because there are just so many. But I totally understanding wanting to read them in order and not finding a later book worth the payoff of reading a bunch of others to get to it! That’s part of why I want to try reading by trope a bit, because I also cannot commit to an entire series just to get to someone’s favorite


  2. I realized that I’ve read out of series order a lot when trying new to me historical authors, but I’m incredibly reluctant to do that in other sub-genres! I think, too, having favorite authors where you’re going to read everything from them and that dominates your reading habits in a specific genre makes it really easy to fall into that being your mindset for other people.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I think the favorite authors thing is exactly what happened! But I’ve also enjoyed the sequel baiting, which makes series fun, too. But I’m excited to start trying to read a little bit more by trope! Especially after that Avon panel!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s